Ok. I hate to do this but.....
I like all the following.
Elves, Dragons, Unicorns, Pegasuses, Wizards, Witches, Nyphms, Spirits, Gods, Goddesses, Fairies.
I hate: Princess/Princes unless they are a princess or prince of the above listed myths.
Well, my actual favorite magical creature would be (not in the option) a Dragon of the thunder realm, or a Chimera-a three headed beast:
head 1: Ram
head 2: Lion
Tail 1: Snake head
JUST from the list ill sai Vampire, Unicorn (not girly like), Pegasus (same as unicorn),
Fairy(dark fairies!)...if its not from the list...dragons (blue black or red...or combined the 3 colors XD), the hippogriff, the phoenix bird...and i cant remember more...but i think those are my fav. ^^